Tuesday, September 19, 2017

In case you don't get it...


David Beckworth, in The Knowledge Problem in Monetary Policy at Mercatus:

Inflation is caused by both supply and demand shocks. Monetary policy can only productively address the latter, but discerning which type of shock has caused inflation in a particular instance is almost impossible for Fed officials to do in real time.

In case you don't get it, Beckworth draws a picture:


See the two circles at the top of the picture? How do we know there are only two circles? It's an assumption. Maybe the picture should look like this:


What could be in that third circle? Here's a thought: policy. Maybe it's policy that's causing the inflation problem. And maybe the solution is not to tighten or loosen, but to try something else with the money. Something like keeping an eye on the ratio of credit to money.

Imagine that.

1 comment:

The Arthurian said...


Note that if you insist on failing to distinguish between money and credit, a concept like the ratio of credit to money will elude you.